Rent vs. Buy in 2025: What’s Really the Smarter Move for Vancouver?

We’ve all heard it: “Renting is so much cheaper — why buy?”

There’s truth to that — especially when interest rates are higher and home prices in Vancouver feel out of reach.

But like all major money decisions, the smart move depends on your city, your numbers, and your goals. Let’s break it down.

The “Pro-Rent” List

1. Better Cash Flow: Rent payments are often lower than a mortgage, especially in high-cost cities like Vancouver. A renter might pay $3,000 for a 2-bedroom, while a buyer could be paying $3,800 with today’s rates. That’s real breathing room month-to-month.

2. More Flexibility: If you plan to move within a few years or want the freedom to relocate for work, renting keeps you mobile — no need to worry about selling in a down market.

3. Less Hassle: When the roof leaks or the plumbing fails, it’s your landlord’s problem — not yours. That peace of mind has a value of its own.

The Other Side of the Story: Why Buying Still Wins Long-Term, especially in for Vancouver business owners.

1. The “Forced Savings” Plan

When you pay rent, 100% goes to someone else’s mortgage. When you pay your mortgage, part of that payment builds equity — an asset that grows every month you own your home.

In Vancouver, where price appreciation historically outpaces inflation, this equity growth can be significant over 10–15 years. Even modest annual growth of 3–4% can turn into six figures in tax-free wealth.

2. The Power of Tax-Free Gains

In Canada, when you sell your principal residence, your profit is tax-free — a huge advantage in a city where homes often appreciate over time.

Compare that to:

• TFSA: Great for tax-free growth, but capped at ~$102,000 (2025).

• RRSP: Tax-deferred, but you pay when you withdraw.

• Home: Unlimited growth potential — completely tax-free.

  
  

In Vancouver’s market, that can mean hundreds of thousands of dollars sheltered from tax.

3. Built-In Tax Breaks (Especially for the Self-Employed)

If you work from home, part of your mortgage interest, property tax, utilities, and even maintenance costs may be deductible as business expenses.

While renters can claim small deductions, homeowners often benefit far more — helping offset higher monthly costs.

Let’s Run the Math: A Vancouver Example

Let’s Run the Math: A Vancouver Example (at 4% interest)

• Renting: $3,000/month for a 2-bedroom condo

• Buying the same condo: $900,000 purchase price

  • 20% down = $180,000

  • Mortgage = $720,000

  • 5-year fixed rate at 4.0% → ~$3,800/month mortgage payment

  • Add $600/month for strata, insurance & property tax

  • Total = $4,400/month

    
    

At first glance, renting still looks cheaper — about $1,400/month less.

But here’s what happens over 10 years:

• You’ll pay down roughly $170,000 in principal (equity).

• If the property appreciates at just 3% per year, the $900,000 home is worth ~$1.21M — a $310,000 tax-free gain.

  
  

That’s a total wealth increase of ~$480,000 in equity and appreciation — and that’s without accounting for rent inflation or tax advantages.

Meanwhile, renters will have spent ~$360,000 on rent with no equity or ownership growth.

What to Do Now

1. Know Your Time Horizon: If you’ll stay in Vancouver for 5+ years, buying often makes more sense. If not, renting gives flexibility.

2. Run the Numbers (Don’t Guess): Online calculators are a start — but a proper mortgage and rent comparison with inflation, appreciation, and tax factors tells the real story.

3. Build a Team: Work with a mortgage broker, financial planner, and accountant to see your full 360° picture — not just the monthly payment.

Bottom line: In Vancouver, buying still tends to win in the long run — especially when you factor in equity growth and tax-free appreciation. But short-term renters can still come out ahead with the right savings plan.

Curious what the math looks like for your situation? Let’s connect — I can help you crunch the numbers and see what makes the most sense for your next move.

Get In Touch